Step 1: write down your workflow
List the steps from a requirement appearing to a placement starting, and mark who does each one today.
- Finding requirements: boards, vendors, direct clients, forwarded emails.
- Matching: how a recruiter decides which consultant fits.
- Preparing the submission: resume tailoring, rate confirmation, right to represent.
- Sending and tracking: email, portals, follow-ups.
- After submission: interviews, feedback, placement and billing.
Step 2: decide which step is the bottleneck
Software helps most where time is lost. If recruiters spend hours finding and screening postings, you need sourcing and matching. If the issue is lost submissions and no history, you need a record. If billing and onboarding slow you down, you need a back-office system.
Step 3: score the tools on the questions that matter
Use the same questions for every vendor and write down the answers.
- Where do requirements come from, and how often are they refreshed?
- How does matching work? Can a recruiter see why a job matched, or is it a score you cannot inspect?
- Is the resume tailored from the candidate’s real history, and does a person review it before it is sent?
- What does it record about submissions, and can the team see who was sent where?
- Can several recruiters use it with separate queues and an admin view?
- What reports exist, and can you export them?
- How does it fit with your ATS or CRM instead of replacing it?
Step 4: run the demo on your own bench
Give each vendor the same five candidates and the same three requirements. Compare what each tool finds, how quickly, and how much editing the output needs. A scripted demo with sample data tells you very little.
Step 5: check what it does not do
Ask each vendor to list what is not included. Hotlist broadcasts, vendor CRM, payroll, onboarding and timesheets are separate product categories, and a tool that is strong at one is often thin at another.
Red flags in any demo
These deserve a follow-up question.
- Match scores with no explanation.
- Claims about results with no source or time frame.
- Pricing that cannot be explained in terms of seats and candidates.
- No way to export your data.
- Refusing to run on your own data.
Where MatchWire fits
MatchWire covers the front of the funnel: a job feed refreshed every 30 minutes, rule-based matching you can inspect, AI-tailored resumes for matches a recruiter queues, submission tracking and activity reports. It is not an ATS, CRM or hotlist tool, so many teams run it alongside their system of record. Book a demo and bring your own candidates.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need an ATS or CRM as well?
Most firms keep a system of record for compliance, placements and billing. A sourcing and matching tool sits in front of it.
How long should evaluation take?
A week or two is usually enough if you run each demo on the same candidates and requirements.
What should I ask about pricing?
Ask how it scales with seats and candidates, what is included, how to cancel and how to export your data.